Head-to-head

Takeya Deluxe Cold Brew Maker vs Toddy Cold Brew System

The best-selling simple cold brew jug against the café-style concentrate system.

Kettle & Crema is reader-supported. As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. It costs you nothing extra. How this works.

Takeya · Budget

Takeya Deluxe Cold Brew Maker

The easiest, cheapest way to keep cold brew in the fridge all week.

Check price on Amazon.comRead the full review →
Toddy · Mid-range

Toddy Cold Brew System

Big batches of the smoothest, cleanest concentrate.

Check price on Amazon.comRead the full review →

Side by side

Takeya Deluxe Cold Brew MakerToddy Cold Brew System
Price tierBudgetMid-range
Sizes1 quart and 2 quart—
PitcherBPA-free Tritan, airtight lid—
FilterFine mesh, reusableReusable felt pads, optional paper bags
CareDishwasher safe—
Batch—A large jug of concentrate from about 340 g / 12 oz of coffee
Includes—Brewing container, glass decanter with lid
Steep—12–24 hours
Biggest strengthCheap, simple, leak-proofSmoothest, cleanest concentrate
Biggest drawbackFine sediment at the bottom of the jugFelt filters need replacing

Choose the Takeya Deluxe Cold Brew Maker if…

  • You want the cheapest, simplest way to keep cold brew in the fridge.
  • You want it to fit in the fridge door.

Choose the Toddy Cold Brew System if…

  • You want the smoothest, cleanest concentrate.
  • You make large batches to last a week or two.

Our verdict

Most people should start with the Takeya. Choose the Toddy if smoothness matters or you drink a lot of cold brew.

Takeya Deluxe Cold Brew MakerCheck price on Amazon.com
Toddy Cold Brew SystemCheck price on Amazon.com

Our comparisons are research-based, drawn from published specifications, certification, repair information and long-term owner feedback. How we research.